I was gutted when I first found out that Florean and Fortescue was not going to be at The Wizarding World of Harry Potter Hollywood. I believe you can still get butterbeer ice cream from The Three Broomsticks but it’s not the same!
My main concern with this recipe was how to incorporate the cream soda into the ice cream without it affecting the creaminess. Thankfully, by reducing the can of soda down to a third cup, it didn’t change the texture at all and it still had an intense flavor of cream soda. That along with the butterscotch swirled throughout makes this the ultimate butterbeer ice cream. I’m so happy with how this recipe came out and I really hope you enjoy it.
Harry Potter: Butterbeer Ice Cream Recipe